The epistemological status of psychoanalysis has become the object of heated debate in recent years as the evidential basis for its clinical theories and procedures has been increasingly questioned. Objectivists view psychoanalysis as a natural science that can be tested by the same objective methods as any other natural science. On the other side, the advocates of relativism contend that psychoanalytic truths are relative to the situation and standpoint of the observer. It is the contention of the present paper that neither side of this argument recognizes the unique nature of psychoanalytic knowledge, and, therefore, neither position provides an epistemological basis for psychoanalysis. Both the objectivist and relativist viewpoints will be examined in detail to illustrate the fundamental flaws in each position. It will be argued that only a specifically human science standpoint avoids the unresolvable problems of the other two positions and provides a valid epistemological basis for psychoanalytic science.
Download Author: Summers, Frank
1 eBook available.
Free Book Categories
- All Books (1,916)
- Anxiety Disorders (41)
- Behavior Therapy (47)
- Borderline Syndromes (39)
- Brief Therapy (27)
- Chapter eBooks (1,704)
- Child Therapy (95)
- Coming Soon (1)
- Couple Therapy (39)
- Crisis (78)
- Depression (66)
- Eating Disorders (17)
- Family Therapy (69)
- Group Therapy (52)
- Mood Disorder (60)
- New Original Works (49)
- Object Relations (51)
- Psychiatry (73)
- Psychoanalysis (105)
- Psychosomatic (34)
- Psychotherapy (119)
- Psychotherapy and Fiction (62)
- Recently Added (19)
- Schizophrenia (33)
- Sex Therapy (41)
- Substance Abuse (39)
- Suicide (13)
- Supervision (35)
View By Author
Need to find a book by a specific author? Get the complete author list.
Comments
Click Testimonials to view all reader comments and reviews.
Recent Comments
- Shen Adachi on Establishment of Relatedness: “This was a wonderful guide to the sensitivity and humanity needing as the starting place to work effectively with individuals…”
- KC Camacho on The Psychotherapeutic Relationship: 40 Years of Learning to be with Patients: “Though it is still rare, it is becoming more common that psychotherapists are opening their lives for us to learn…”
- Styliani Kontogianni on The Imperfect Therapist: “This very valuable e-book helped me with my assignments during my postgraduate Studies in counseling and Psychotherapy. Especially when I…”
- Nancy on Overcoming Our Relationship Fears:WORKBOOK: “I’m a psychological counselor in China. I love the website and the books you offer for free. Thank you very…”
- Masoud on Dream Analysis in Psychotherapy: “Thank you so much for free access to the pdf of the newest psychology books. In my country all cites…”
- Adambil -Laar Bimi Nixon on Principles of Community Mental Health Practice: “I like your site because I’m a student of Community mental health and I find your books very relevant and…”